Aids to Determining Copyright
In-A-Pinch Flowchart
1. Start
What is the nature of the material you wish to reproduce, and where did you find it?
- A work in a database, website, or digital repository [PROCEED TO #2]
- A published or unpublished work in a library, archive, or special collection [PROCEED TO #3]
- A published or unpublished work in a privately-owned collection [PROCEED TO #3]
- A published or unpublished work that you have lawfully acquired as an original or a copy [PROCEED TO #4]
2. Licenses + Contracts
Is use of the material subject to licenses or contracts?
- Already covered by a use license, such as Creative Commons licenses or open source licenses? [PROCEED TO #8]
- Subject to contractual limitations on use, such as terms of use agreements? [PROCEED TO #8]
- None of the above [PROCEED TO #4]
- Unsure [PROCEED TO #5]
3. Policies + Special Circumstances
Is use of the material governed by institutional policies or special circumstances?
- The repository that holds the material requires permission for you to publish, duplicate, or distribute it [PROCEED TO #6]
- The repository that holds the material maintains specific policies about its use [PROCEED TO #8]
- The material is unpublished and contains personal information about or pictures of particular living individuals [PROCEED TO #6]
- None of the above [PROCEED TO #4]
- Unsure [PROCEED TO #5]
4. Public Domain Eligibility
Does the material you seek to use fall under the public domain?
- Material meets any of the following criteria for copyright ineligibility:
- Facts, data, statistics
- Legislative documents including laws, regulations, reports, etc.
- Produced by the United States (federal) government
These materials were never eligible for copyright and are therefore considered part of the public domain. [PROCEED TO #7]
- Material meets any of the following criteria for copyright expiration:
- U.S. work (non-sound recording) published prior to 1926 (as of January 2021)
- U.S. sound recording published prior to 1923 (as of January 2022)
- U.S. work published from 1926-1977, but without a copyright notice
- U.S. work published between 1978 and March 1, 1989 without a copyright notice and not registered within the next five years
- U.S. work published between 1926 and 1963 with a copyright notice, but copyright was not renewed
- Unpublished U.S. work, registered after 1978
- Unpublished and unregistered U.S. work, author died before 1951
- Unpublished and unregistered U.S. work created before 1901, author or death date unknown
These materials are likely considered part of the public domain. [PROCEED TO #7]
- None of the above, or unsure
If the material does not meet any of these criteria, it may be protected by copyright law, but may still be eligible for Fair Use. [PROCEED TO #5]
5. Fair Use Eligibility
Does the nature of the material or how you intend to use it constitute Fair Use?
- Your uses are transformative, i.e. “those that add something new, with a further purpose or different character, and do not substitute for the original use of the work”
- Access will be restricted (for example, to students) or few copies made
- Used for criticism, parody, or comment
- Used for the purposes of teaching, research, or scholarship
- Excerpts used in small quantities
- Non-central portions of the work used
- Used supplemental to a copy of the original work that you have lawfully acquired/purchased
- Used in a manner that will not significantly affect the market for the copyrighted work
- Used for a non-profit educational institution
- The original work is published
- The original work is non-fiction, or factual in nature
These factors may make the work eligible for Fair Use, “a legal doctrine that promotes freedom of expression by permitting the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances.” The more boxes you can check, the more favorable the chances that you can use the material safely under the umbrella of Fair Use.
If a majority of the criteria for Fair Use have been met, [PROCEED TO #9]
Otherwise, you may need to secure permission to use the material. [PROCEED TO #6]
6. Permissions
Have you secured permission from the copyright holder to use the material?
- Yes, my request was granted [PROCEED TO #8]
- Yes, I purchased a license or permissions for use [PROCEED TO #8]
- No, my request was not granted [PROCEED TO #10]
- No, I received no response to my request [PROCEED TO #10]
- No, because I cannot locate or identify the copyright holder (a so-called “orphan work”) [PROCEED TO #11]
7. Use (attribution suggested)
8. Use within terms of agreement
9. Use with documentation of Fair Use
(For example, through the Fair Use Evaluator tool)
10. Seek an alternative
Is there another item you can use that has less risk attached to it?
11. Seek help from a pro
You can find guidance in this Copyright for Educators: A Guide to the Law and Fair Use libguide, or reach out to a librarian.